How to Buy a Mattress Online: A 6-Step Guide

In this guide
To buy a mattress online successfully: work out the firmness you need from your sleep position and body weight, choose a mattress type (memory foam, latex, pocket coil or hybrid), set a realistic budget, compare construction details rather than marketing names, and only buy from a seller with a clear sleep trial, warranty and a real phone number and address. This six-step process takes about an hour and avoids the most common online mistakes.
Key takeaways
- Firmness is the most important decision; base it on how you sleep and what you weigh, not on reviews.
- A good queen mattress in Canada typically costs $800–$1,500; quality options start from about $400.
- Compare materials, foam densities, coil type and height, since model names often differ between stores.
- Read the trial terms before buying: break-in period, refund vs. exchange, pickup fees.
- If you are near a showroom, trying your shortlist for 20 minutes removes most of the risk.
Step 1: Work out your firmness
| How you sleep | Under 130 lb | 130–230 lb | Over 230 lb |
|---|---|---|---|
| Side | Plush | Medium | Medium-firm |
| Back | Medium | Medium-firm | Firm |
| Stomach | Medium-firm | Firm | Firm to extra firm |
| Combination | Medium | Medium-firm | Firm |
If you have back pain, medium-firm is the best starting point for most people. Our Mattress Selector does this calculation for you in five questions.
Step 2: Choose a mattress type
- Memory foam: deep contouring and the best motion isolation; can sleep warm. Good for side sleepers and light sleepers.
- Natural latex: responsive, cool and very durable; costs more. Good for hot sleepers and those who move around.
- Pocket coil: supportive, bouncy and breathable with strong edges. Good for back and stomach sleepers and heavier bodies.
- Hybrid: foam or latex over pocket coils; the best all-rounder and the most popular choice we sell.
Compare them in depth in memory foam vs. latex and memory foam vs. pocket coil.
Step 3: Set your budget
You can buy a mattress for $300, but very cheap mattresses often use low-density foam that softens within two or three years. For daily use, most people find the best value between $800 and $1,500 in queen. Canadian-made Dreamstar mattresses start from about $399; name brands such as Beautyrest, Serta and Sealy generally start higher. Think in cost per year: a $1,200 mattress that lasts ten years costs less than a $500 one replaced after four.
Step 4: Compare construction, not names
Large brands often sell the same mattress under different names at different retailers, so search results and reviews can be misleading. Compare:
- Overall height and comfort layer thickness
- Foam types and densities (memory foam 4 lb/ft³+ for durability)
- Coil type and count (individually wrapped pocket coils for less motion transfer)
- Edge support and cooling features
- Where it is made and what certifications the foam carries
Step 5: Vet the seller
Check reviews of the store, not just the mattress. Look for a physical address, a phone number that a person answers, and clear delivery terms. Ask whether there are any current promotions; many stores have them, and some will tell you about upcoming sales if you ask.
Step 6: Read the trial, return and warranty terms
Most sellers offer a 90 to 120-night trial, but the details differ: some require 30 nights before a return, some offer exchange only, and some charge pickup or restocking fees. Warranties are typically 10 years; check the impression depth that counts as a defect and the foundation requirement. Our exchange and return policy is published in full.
Lower the risk: if you are in the GTA, shortlist online and then visit our North York showroom to lie on your top three. It takes 20 minutes, our staff are not on commission, and you can still order online afterwards.
Popular mattresses to start with
Answer five quick questions and the Mattress Selector will recommend the firmness, type and three specific mattresses for you.
Frequently asked questions
Is it a good idea to buy a mattress online?
Yes, if you know the firmness and type you want and buy from a reputable seller with a fair sleep trial. If you are unsure, try your shortlist in a showroom first.
How much should I spend on a mattress?
Most people find the best value between $800 and $1,500 for a queen. Quality budget options start around $400; luxury models run $2,000 and up.
How do I know what firmness to buy online?
Base it on your sleep position and body weight: side sleepers need softer, stomach sleepers firmer, and heavier sleepers should go one step firmer than average.
What if I do not like the mattress?
Use the sleep trial. Give it at least 30 nights to adjust, then contact the seller about an exchange or return under their policy.


